Own Luxury Homes®
New York vs Florida Income Tax: NYC Combined Rate Guide
NY state 10.9% + NYC 3.876% = 14.776% combined vs FL 0%. Saves $70K/yr on $500K, $143K on $1M, $725K on $5M. NY statutory residency trap: maintain NY 'permanent place of abode' AND 183+ days = taxed as NY resident regardless of FL domicile. Retirement distributions taxed by NY; FL domicile before taking distributions saves 10.9%+ on every distribution. Own Luxury Homes® verifies through the 12-Point Agent Integrity Audit™.
Home › Markets › New York vs Florida Income Tax Guide › New York vs Florida Income Tax: NYC Combined Rate Guide
New York vs Florida Income Tax: NYC Combined Rate Guide
$9.2B
Income that left New York City for Palm Beach and Miami-Dade counties in five years through recent years
14.776%
Combined New York state and NYC income tax rate — compared to Florida’s 0%
12
Point Integrity Audit dimensions Own Luxury Homes® verifies before any specialist introduction
$7.35M
New York estate tax exemption in currently — estates above 105% of this threshold are taxed on the full amount
Tax information reflects current published rules and rates. State income tax, estate tax, and domicile rules are complex and change. Consult a CPA and tax attorney licensed in both your origin and destination states before making any residency or real estate decision based on tax strategy.
The New York income tax savings are the largest of any state-to-Florida migration. No other origin state extracts 14.776% from its high earners.
Own Luxury Homes® NAMED CONCEPT
Own Luxury Homes® 12-Point Agent Integrity Audit™
The Own Luxury Homes® standard: a specialist with genuine expertise in migration buyer needs — tax transition coordination, market selection, and insurance navigation — verified through documented transaction history before any introduction.
Own Luxury Homes® Market Intelligence.
NYC Combined Tax Rate vs Florida by Income
| Annual Income | NY State + NYC Tax | FL Tax | Annual Savings | 10-Year Savings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500K | ~$70,000–$73,000 | $0 | ~$70,000 | ~$700,000 |
| $1M | ~$138,000–$147,760 | $0 | ~$143,000 | ~$1.43M |
| $3M | ~$427,000–$443,000 | $0 | ~$435,000 | ~$4.35M |
| $5M | ~$712,000–$738,000 | $0 | ~$725,000 | ~$7.25M |
| $10M | ~$1.43M–$1.48M | $0 | ~$1.45M | ~$14.5M |
Ranges reflect blended effective rates at various income compositions. Top combined NYC rate: 14.776%. NY state alone for those outside NYC: 10.9% at highest bracket. Consult a CPA for exact savings calculation based on your specific income composition.
The New Jersey Commuter Tax Dimension
New Jersey residents who work in New York City face an additional tax dimension: (1) NYC non-resident income tax: New Jersey residents who work in NYC pay New York City’s non-resident earnings tax on income earned in NYC. New Jersey also taxes the same income. New Jersey provides a credit for taxes paid to other states, but the credit may not fully offset the double taxation burden. (2) New Jersey state income tax: New Jersey’s top marginal rate is 10.75% — comparable to New York state. A New Jersey resident who works in NYC pays NJ income tax on all income plus NYC non-resident earnings tax on NYC-earned income. (3) The Florida move for NJ/NYC workers: establishing Florida domicile eliminates NJ state income tax on investment income and all income not sourced to NJ or NYC. NYC-sourced earned income (wages from NYC employer) continues to be taxed by NY regardless of domicile. The benefit is primarily on investment income, business income, and income from non-NY sources.
Investment and Passive Income: The Domicile Savings
For high-net-worth New Yorkers with significant investment portfolios, the Florida domicile savings extend beyond earned income: (1) Dividends and interest: New York taxes dividend and interest income as ordinary income. A $10M portfolio generating 4% in dividends: $400K income, $55,760–$59,104 in New York tax. Florida: $0. (2) Capital gains: New York taxes capital gains as ordinary income — no preferential long-term rate. A $2M stock gain: $270,000–$295,520 in New York tax. Florida: $0. (3) Retirement distributions: New York taxes IRA, 401(k), and pension distributions as ordinary income. Florida does not. A $500K annual retirement distribution: approximately $50,000–$54,500 in New York tax. Florida: $0. (4) The retirement planning implication: establishing Florida domicile before taking significant retirement distributions produces meaningful savings over the distribution period. A 20-year retirement at $400K in annual distributions: approximately $800,000–$900,000 in cumulative NY state tax avoided.
New York’s Statutory Residency Rule: The NYC Apartment Problem
New York’s statutory residency rule is the most dangerous trap for NYC residents who “move” to Florida: (1) The rule: even if your domicile is Florida, New York taxes you as a full resident if you maintain a “permanent place of abode” in New York AND spend more than 183 days in New York in a calendar year. (2) What “permanent place of abode” means: any residential property you can use in New York — an apartment you own, a cooperative unit, a house you own or rent — qualifies as a permanent place of abode even if you’re not living there. (3) The NYC apartment: a Florida-domiciled person who keeps their Upper East Side co-op or Tribeca condo has a permanent place of abode in New York. If they visit New York more than 183 days: New York taxes them as a full-year resident. 183 days sounds like a lot until you count weekend visits, dinners with family, and occasional business trips. (4) The clean break: selling the New York property eliminates the permanent place of abode and the statutory residency exposure. Alternatively: keep the property but limit New York days to 182 or fewer and document each.
Ryan Brown, Principal Broker & CEO Own Luxury Homes®
"The New York buyer who moves to Florida and keeps their Park Avenue apartment because they’re not quite ready to let it go has kept the statutory residency trap alive. The apartment is a “permanent place of abode.” If they visit New York more than 183 days, New York taxes them as a resident. Counting is the solution: 182 days maximum, documented. Or selling the apartment. The tax savings are real either way. The discipline to stay under 183 days is real work. Selling the apartment is cleaner."
Related Own Luxury Homes® Buyer Guides
New York to Florida Guides: Income Tax Savings — Estate Tax Cliff — Real Estate Comparison — NY Domicile Guide — NYC to Palm Beach — NYC to Miami — Co-op to Condo — Finance Executive — Agent Guide
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the combined New York City income tax rate?
NY state top marginal rate: 10.9% (income above $25M). NYC local income tax: 3.876%. Combined: up to 14.776%. Florida: 0%. Savings on $1M income: ~$140,000-$147,760/year.
Do New Jersey residents who commute to NYC benefit from moving to Florida?
Yes, primarily on investment income and non-NYC-sourced income. NYC-earned wages continue to be taxed by NY even after FL domicile. NJ income tax eliminated on non-NJ-sourced income after FL domicile.
Does New York tax retirement distributions?
Yes, as ordinary income at full rates. Florida does not. Establishing FL domicile before taking significant distributions saves 10.9%+ on all distributions.
What is New York's statutory residency rule?
If you maintain a NY 'permanent place of abode' AND spend 183+ days in NY: NY taxes you as a full resident regardless of FL domicile. Selling the NY property eliminates the exposure. Keeping the property: limit NY days to 182 or fewer and document every day.
"The introduction Own Luxury Homes® makes is to a specialist with documented closing history in your specific market — not the county, not the metro, the submarket you're actually selling or buying in. That's the standard we verify before your name goes anywhere."
— Ryan Brown, Principal Broker & CEO, Own Luxury Homes® (FL License BK3626873)