Own Luxury Homes®
Conventional vs FHA vs VA vs USDA: 2026 Comparison
VA first for eligible buyers: 0% down, no monthly MI, best total cost. USDA: 0% down; 0.35% annual fee beats FHA MIP (0.55%). Conventional beats FHA at 680+ credit: PMI removable; FHA MIP permanent on <10% down. FHA: 500-619 credit gap-filler; not first choice if alternatives exist. Mistake: veteran takes FHA instead of VA = $15-30K extra over 10 years. Own Luxury Homes® 12-Point Agent Integrity Audit™ — no lender.
Conventional vs FHA vs VA vs USDA: The Honest Side-by-Side Comparison
Every mortgage comparison guide online is written by a lender, a mortgage broker, or a financial media site with affiliate lender relationships. Every one of them has a product to sell you. This one doesn't. What follows is the comparison as a buyer's agent would give it: honest, with the downsides of each product named clearly, and with a specific recommendation framework based on your actual profile.
The Master Comparison Table
| Feature | Conventional | FHA | VA | USDA | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who qualifies | Anyone meeting credit/income standards | Anyone meeting FHA minimums | Veterans, active duty, eligible spouses | Income-qualified buyers in eligible areas | |||||
| Minimum down payment | 3% (first-time); 5% otherwise | 3.5% (580+ credit); 10% (500–579) | 0% | 0% | |||||
| Minimum credit score | 620–640 (lender varies) | 500–580 (lender varies) | No VA minimum; lenders typically 580–620+ | 640+ typically | |||||
| Mortgage insurance | PMI if <20% down; REMOVABLE at 80% LTV | MIP required always; NOT REMOVABLE on <10% down post-June 2013 loans | None — no monthly MI ever | 0.35%/yr annual guarantee fee; not removable while in USDA | |||||
| Upfront insurance cost | None | 1.75% of loan amount (rollable) | 1.25–3.3% funding fee (rollable; waived for disabled veterans) | 1.0% guarantee fee (rollable) | |||||
| Loan limits | $806,500 standard; up to $1,209,750 high-cost | $541,287–$1,249,125 by county | No limit for full-entitlement borrowers | No official limit; income/area restrict | |||||
| Property types | Primary, second home, investment (different rates) | Primary residence only | Primary residence only | Primary residence only; eligible area | |||||
| Debt-to-income maximum | Typically 45–50% with strong compensating factors | Up to 56.9% with strong factors | No official limit; lender-specific | Typically 41–44% | |||||
| Income limits | None | None | None | Yes — household income must be under ~115% of area median income | |||||
| Geographic limits | None | None | None | Yes — property must be in USDA-eligible area (more areas qualify than most expect) | |||||
| Best rate scenario | 720+ credit; 20%+ down | 620–679 credit; limited down payment | Any eligible veteran; especially with higher DTI | 640+ credit; eligible area | |||||
| Source: FHFA, FHA, VA, USDA program guidelines as of 2026. Individual lender overlays may be stricter. | |||||||||
When Each Loan Type Wins
VA Wins When: You Are Eligible
If you qualify for a VA loan, start here every time. 0% down payment, no monthly mortgage insurance, competitive rates (often lower than conventional), no loan limit for full-entitlement borrowers. The only cost: a one-time funding fee (2.15% first use, 3.3% subsequent use, 1.25% with 5%+ down). Disabled veterans: funding fee waived entirely. For eligible buyers, VA produces the lowest total cost of borrowing in almost every scenario when compared to FHA and conventional with PMI. The only time VA isn't optimal: subsequent use when the funding fee (3.3%) combined with higher rates makes conventional with a down payment competitive. Run the math on both.
USDA Wins When: You Qualify and the Property Is Eligible
USDA is the most underutilized loan program in the US. Buyers assume it's "for farms" when in reality many suburban properties within 30 miles of mid-sized cities qualify. Check the USDA eligibility map before assuming you don't qualify. 0% down, income below ~115% of area median income, and an eligible property produces a loan with lower total cost than FHA in most scenarios. The annual guarantee fee (0.35%) is cheaper than FHA MIP (0.55%) and cheaper than conventional PMI at low down payments.
Conventional Wins When: Credit Is 680+ and PMI Is Temporary
For buyers with 680+ credit who plan to reach 20% equity within 10 years, conventional with PMI almost always produces lower total cost than FHA. The reason: conventional PMI is removed at 80% LTV; FHA MIP on a <10% down loan is permanent. At 720+ credit, conventional rates improve further and the advantage grows. Conventional also wins for: investment properties (FHA/VA/USDA prohibit), second homes, and buyers who need loan amounts above FHA limits.
FHA Wins When: Credit Is Below 680 and You Can't Qualify for Conventional
FHA fills the gap when conventional is unavailable due to credit or income factors. 500–579 credit with 10% down. 580–619 credit with 3.5% down. Higher DTI ratios than conventional allows. But understand the MIP cost before choosing FHA over conventional: if your credit is 620–679 and you can qualify for conventional, run both numbers. The conventional PMI that comes off in 8 years may produce lower total cost than FHA MIP for life, even if the monthly payment is slightly higher initially.
The Costly Mistakes: Wrong Loan for Your Profile
| Mistake | Who It Affects | The Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Veteran takes FHA instead of VA | Military buyer whose agent or lender didn't ask about VA eligibility | No monthly MI benefit lost; upfront MIP cost added; typically $15,000–30,000 over 10 years |
| 680+ credit buyer takes FHA instead of conventional | First-time buyer pushed toward FHA without comparison | Lifetime MIP vs removable PMI; $15,000–20,000 additional cost over 10 years |
| Rural buyer takes FHA without checking USDA eligibility | Buyer who didn't know about USDA or assumed they don't qualify | Annual USDA fee (0.35%) beats FHA MIP (0.55%) on most loan sizes |
| VA buyer uses subsequent use without comparing to conventional | Veteran on 2nd+ VA loan with 3.3% funding fee and 0% down | At 3.3% funding fee: run the math vs 5–10% conventional down payment; sometimes conventional wins |
“The loan type conversation happens before any other mortgage discussion. I ask every buyer two questions first: "Are you a veteran, active duty, or eligible surviving spouse?" and "Are you buying in a rural or suburban area?" Those two answers determine whether VA or USDA is available. If neither applies, we look at credit score and down payment to find where conventional vs FHA falls. The wrong loan type is one of the most expensive mistakes buyers make — and it's almost always the result of talking to only one lender.”
— Ryan Brown, Principal Broker & CEO, Own Luxury Homes®
Which is better: FHA or conventional loan?
Depends on your credit score. Under 620: FHA is usually the only option. 620–679: compare both; FHA may have lower payment but conventional PMI disappears. 680+: conventional almost always wins on 10-year total cost because FHA MIP on <10% down loans cannot be removed; conventional PMI can.
Is a VA loan always better than FHA?
For eligible buyers, yes — in almost every scenario. VA: 0% down, no monthly mortgage insurance, competitive rates, no loan limit (full entitlement). FHA: 3.5% down, MIP required for life on <10% down loans. The only exception: VA subsequent use with 3.3% funding fee at 0% down vs conventional with 10%+ down. Run the math; sometimes conventional wins on subsequent VA use.
Who qualifies for a USDA loan?
Two requirements: (1) income below approximately 115% of area median income (check USDA income limits by county), (2) property in a USDA-eligible area (check the USDA eligibility map; many suburban properties qualify). Primary residence only. 0% down payment. 640+ credit score typically required by lenders. More buyers and properties qualify than most assume.
What credit score do I need for each loan type?
Conventional: 620–640 minimum; 680+ for competitive rates; 720+ for best rates. FHA: 500–579 with 10% down; 580+ with 3.5% down. VA: No VA minimum; lenders typically require 580–620+. USDA: 640+ typically. Jumbo: 700–720+ typically. Credit score is the single biggest variable in both your eligibility and your rate.
Own Luxury Homes® — no lender relationship. The comparison your lender won't give you. 12-Point Agent Integrity Audit™. Talk to a specialist ›
"The introduction Own Luxury Homes® makes is to a specialist with documented closing history in your specific market — not the county, not the metro, the submarket you're actually selling or buying in. That's the standard we verify before your name goes anywhere."
— Ryan Brown, Principal Broker & CEO, Own Luxury Homes® (FL License BK3626873)