› Vacation Home Hub

Home › Markets › Vacation Home & Second Home › Best US Markets for Short-Term Rental Investment

Best US Markets for Short-Term Rental Investment

The best STR investment market is not simply the one with the highest gross revenue — it is the intersection of strong gross yield, a permissive and stable regulatory environment, a liquid resale market, and an entry price that supports a viable return model. Markets with the highest gross revenue (New York C...

Smoky Mountains / East Tennessee

The Smoky Mountains corridor — Gatlinburg, Pigeon Forge, Sevierville, and surrounding Sevier County, Tennessee — is the most STR-saturated market in the eastern US and consistently among the top 5 STR markets nationally by gross revenue. Key characteristics: (1) Demand: the Great Smoky Mountains National Park is the most-visited national park in the US (12+ million visitors annually). Demand is year-round with peaks in fall foliage season (October) and summer. (2) Regulatory environment: highly permissive. Sevier County has no STR ban and minimal licensing requirements. The city of Gatlinburg allows STR with a permit. Regulatory risk is low compared to coastal markets. (3) Entry prices: $400K–$1.5M for cabin STR properties in the 2–4 bedroom range that generate $60,000–$120,000+ in annual gross revenue. (4) Gross yield: 8–15% gross on the purchase price for well-positioned cabin properties. Net yields after management fees (25–30%), property costs, and taxes: 5–10%. (5) Supply saturation risk: the Smoky Mountains market has seen significant new cabin construction since 2020. Occupancy rates have compressed from peak levels; operators must differentiate on amenity (outdoor hot tubs, game rooms, mountain views) to maintain premium ADR (average daily rate).

Orlando / Osceola County Florida

The Orlando / Kissimmee / Davenport corridor in Osceola County is the largest STR market by transaction volume in the US and specifically zoned to accommodate short-term rental in resort community districts. Key characteristics: (1) Demand: Walt Disney World, Universal Studios, SeaWorld, and Convention Center events drive 75+ million annual visitors to the Orlando metro. Demand is global and year-round with specific peaks around school holidays, spring break, and convention season. (2) Regulatory environment: Osceola County’s resort community zoning specifically designates certain communities (Reunion Resort, ChampionsGate, Windsor Hills, Storey Lake, Solara Resort) as STR-eligible. Orange County (City of Orlando proper) is significantly more restrictive — verifying the county boundary is essential. (3) Entry prices: $400K–$1.5M for 3–8 bedroom resort community homes. (4) Gross yield: 8–12% gross for premium resort community properties. Net yields after management fees (20–25%), HOA, taxes, and property costs: 5–8%. (5) STR community selection: each resort community in Osceola County has its own HOA governing rental rules, occupancy limits, and amenity access. Due diligence on the specific community’s STR rules is required even within Osceola County’s permissive zone.

Scottsdale / Phoenix Metro (Arizona)

Arizona’s 2016 STR preemption law makes the Phoenix metro — including Scottsdale, Tempe, Chandler, and Mesa — one of the most STR-secure investment environments in the US. The preemption prevents municipalities from banning STR outright, creating legal certainty. Key characteristics: (1) Demand: Scottsdale is a top-10 US destination for bachelor/bachelorette parties, corporate events, spring training baseball, and golf tourism. Demand spikes in winter (November–April) when snowbirds and sports visitors drive peak ADRs. (2) Regulatory environment: STR is legal statewide. Scottsdale requires STR licensing and enforces noise and occupancy rules but cannot ban STR. Regulatory risk is the lowest of any major US STR market. (3) Entry prices: $600K–$3M for luxury homes in STR-productive areas (Old Town Scottsdale, Paradise Valley, Gainey Ranch). (4) Gross yield: 6–10% gross for well-positioned luxury homes. Peak-season ADRs of $1,000–$5,000+/night for premium pool homes. (5) Seasonality risk: Arizona’s summer (June–September) is extremely slow for STR due to 110+ degree temperatures. Cash flow models must account for 2–3 months of near-zero revenue.

Gulf Coast Florida and Outer Banks NC

Gulf Coast Florida (30A / Destin / Panama City Beach): the Emerald Coast of Northwest Florida — 30A corridor, Destin, Panama City Beach, and Rosemary Beach — is among the most productive beach STR markets in the eastern US. White sand beaches, calm Gulf water, and no state income tax on rental income. Entry prices: $600K–$5M+ for Gulf-front and Gulf-view properties. Gross yields: 7–12% for Gulf-front; 5–8% for Gulf-view. Regulatory environment: generally permissive at the county level (Walton, Okaloosa counties), though some communities (Seaside, Rosemary Beach) have HOA restrictions on rental character. Outer Banks, NC: consistently one of the top-performing beach STR markets in the US. Kill Devil Hills, Nags Head, Duck, Corolla, and southern Outer Banks communities all allow STR with licensing. The Outer Banks market is primarily drive-to (from the Mid-Atlantic and Southeast) with concentrated summer demand (June–August). 4–8 bedroom oceanfront homes generate $150,000–$400,000+ in annual gross revenue. Entry prices: $800K–$4M+ for oceanfront. Net yields: 5–9% on oceanfront after management and costs.

Own Luxury Homes® Related Hubs: 1031 Exchange — Privacy & Asset Protection — International Buyer — Multigenerational Living

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best US market for STR investment?

Depends on entry price tolerance, regulatory risk preference, and seasonality comfort. Best regulatory stability: Scottsdale/Phoenix metro (state preemption law). Best gross yields: Smoky Mountains (cabin market). Best demand volume: Orlando (Osceola County resort communities). Best beach market for yield: 30A/Gulf Coast or Outer Banks. No single market is best across all dimensions.

What gross yield should I expect from an STR investment?

Well-positioned STR properties in top US markets produce 8–15% gross yields on the purchase price. Net yields after management fees (20–30%), property taxes, insurance, HOA, maintenance, and mortgage: 4–9%. Properties outside the top-tier locations or with below-average amenities produce gross yields of 5–8%.

Is Airbnb still legal in New York City?

Effectively no for full-home rentals. NYC Local Law 18 (effective September 2023) requires STR hosts to register with the city and be present during guest stays — making non-owner-occupied STR impractical. The law essentially ended the full-home STR market in NYC.

Which US markets have the most STR regulatory risk?

Markets with the highest risk of future STR restriction: urban markets with housing supply constraints (Los Angeles, San Francisco, Boston, Seattle) and tourist-saturated cities facing housing affordability pressure (New Orleans, Nashville in residential zones, Miami Beach). Markets with the lowest regulatory risk: Arizona (state preemption), Osceola County FL (zoning specifically designed for STR), and rural/mountain markets with minimal housing pressure.