
Home › Winter Garden, FL › Neighborhoods › Hickory Hammock
Own Luxury Homes®
Hickory Hammock, Winter Garden: Townhomes and Johns Lake Estates Under One Name
Hickory Hammock in Winter Garden is a 491-home community on Johns Lake, built from 2014 to 2020, where 100 townhomes with a median county just value of $364,440 share a name and a CDD with single-family homes whose median is $829,490.
Local real estate expertise for fine homes and luxury properties.
Where every client is treated like a million-dollar client.


Hickory Hammock Facts From County Records
- Homes: 491, all in the City of Winter Garden: 391 single-family homes and 100 townhomes.
- Values by type: single-family median $829,490 with about 3,530 square feet of living area; townhome median $364,440 with about 1,900 square feet. Across the community, most values fall below $1,716,170, the 90th percentile.
- Build years: 2014 to 2020, with 177 homes finished in 2015 alone.
- Lots and pools: single-family lots have a median of about 0.27 acre; 196 homes have a pool.
- Johns Lake: 50 parcels touch the 1,619-acre lake.
Winter Garden, FL
Your Real Estate Goals. Your Next Step.

Buying a Home
Begin with local real estate expertise to compare properties, understand the market, and explore the ownership considerations that matter before making an offer.

Selling a Home
Understand your home’s place in the market. Consider competing properties, likely buyers, pricing, preparation, presentation, and timing.

Relocating or Considering a Second Home?
The destination matters as much as the residence. Consider how you intend to use the home, access, lifestyle, management, and the responsibilities of ownership.
Hickory Hammock Homes for Sale: Compare Like With Like
A community median of $756,440 describes almost no actual home here, because it sits between a townhome group and a single-family group that are priced more than $460,000 apart. Our agents split comparables by type first, then by lake frontage, lot size and finish. A lakefront estate is compared with other Johns Lake frontage, not with an inland home a street away.
Flood Zones Along the Shore
Of the 491 parcels, 145, about 30%, overlap a FEMA special flood hazard area (zones A and AE) by more than 1% of their area on the county's flood layer. That share is far higher than in most Winter Garden communities and follows the lake. Lenders require flood insurance when a financed building is in one of these zones, so get a quote for the specific home before you commit.
The Hickory Hammock CDD and Property Tax
County parcel records place every Hickory Hammock parcel in the Hickory Hammock Community Development District, a separate local government with its own budget and assessments, in addition to any HOA dues. For the property tax, City of Winter Garden millage of 16.2943 (2025 final) gives estimates before exemptions (the seller's current bill may be far lower; check a specific home with the Orange County Property Appraiser's tax estimator) of about $13,000 to $14,000 a year at the single-family median and about $5,500 to $6,500 at the townhome median. Your own bill resets from your just value after the sale.
Thinking of Selling in Hickory Hammock
Buyers here are often choosing between frontage and an inland lot, or between a townhome and a starter detached home. Our listing agents show where your home sits on that ladder, with the frontage, dock, flood zone, district assessment and HOA figures set out clearly, and price it against sales of the same type.
Nearby Alternatives
Twin Waters, between Johns Lake and Lake Avalon, has large homes built 2016 to 2021; Avalon Reserve is a smaller community from 2013 to 2015; and Carriage Pointe offers 2006 to 2011 homes at lower values. See our lakefront guide, the neighborhoods guide, or ask our Winter Garden agents.



The Own Luxury Homes® Perspective
One name, two products: Hickory Hammock's median hides both.
Searches and price summaries treat Hickory Hammock as one market. County records show it isn't. One hundred townhomes and 391 single-family homes, with medians more than $460,000 apart, share the name, the association and the CDD.
A buyer reading the community median, or a seller pricing from it, would be wrong for nearly every home. The lakefront estates at the top of the range are a third product again, with their own comparables on Johns Lake.
In Hickory Hammock, price a home only against its own type and setting, because the community median mixes products that never compete with each other.
Hickory Hammock Questions
Why does a Hickory Hammock agent split comparables by type?
Because townhomes and single-family homes here sit at very different value levels. Our specialist compares each home with its own type, then with frontage or inland lots, and checks the CDD and flood zone.
Is Hickory Hammock on Johns Lake?
Yes. County maps show 50 parcels touching the lake.
Does Hickory Hammock have townhomes?
Yes, 100 of its 491 homes are townhomes, about a fifth of the community.
Does Hickory Hammock have a CDD?
County parcel records place every parcel in the Hickory Hammock Community Development District. Ask for the parcel's annual assessment along with HOA dues.
How much of Hickory Hammock is in a flood zone?
About 30%: 145 of 491 parcels overlap a FEMA special flood hazard area by more than 1% of their area. Check the specific parcel on FEMA's map.



OWN LUXURY HOMES®
PERSPECTIVE
A National Perspective on Real Estate, Property, and the Decisions That Matter.
By Ryan Brown
Explore original insights and thoughtful analysis of real estate markets, housing trends, property ownership, and the decisions facing buyers and sellers across America.


A Private, More Intentional Beginning
Tell us about your decision
Tell us what you are buying or selling, where, the approximate price range, your timing, and what matters most.
Speak with a local real estate professional.
Discuss your goals, the property, the market, and the questions that will help you decide how to proceed.
Choose your next step.
Take the time you need. There is no obligation to move forward.

Sources:
Orange County open GIS parcel data, 2026 tax roll (including CDD field) (checked October 2026); Orange County FEMA flood hazard layer and hydrology layer (checked October 2026); FEMA Flood Map Service Center (checked October 2026); Orange County Property Appraiser, 2025 final millage (checked October 2026). Figures: homes on the Hickory Hammock plats; ranges are the 10th to 90th percentile; county just values are tax assessments, not sale prices.
Reviewed by Ryan Brown, Licensed Real Estate Broker and CEO, Own Luxury Homes®






