NAR's Housing Forecasts Keep Missing. Buyers and Sellers Deserve a Clearer Picture.
OWN LUXURY HOMES® — PERSPECTIVE
A National Perspective on Real Estate, Property, and the Decisions That Matter.
By Ryan Brown, CEO & Broker, Own Luxury Homes®
Illustrative editorial image; not a depiction of a specific property or actual listing.
Housing forecasts are not harmless predictions. Buyers use them to decide whether to wait. Sellers use them to decide whether to list. Agents use them to advise clients. And millions of people hear the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) describe where the market is supposedly headed.
But when the same association's chief economist repeatedly forecasts a meaningful rebound that does not arrive, the public deserves more than another optimistic explanation for why the recovery has been delayed.
I am not arguing that an economist must predict every turn correctly. Forecasts are uncertain by nature. My concern is the pattern: the scale of the misses, the repeated expectation that sales are about to rebound, and the way those projections can shape public expectations while the market remains weak.
In my opinion, repeatedly presenting a recovery as just around the corner—without giving equal prominence to the downside risks and the history of forecast errors—is not responsible public communication. It becomes an ethical issue when optimism is allowed to sound like dependable guidance.
The record is measurable. Here are several examples.
The Forecasts Versus What Actually Happened
To keep the comparison fair, these examples focus on existing-home sales volume, not home prices. They compare a forecast made before the year with the eventual annual sales result. A forecast miss does not prove bad faith, but repeated misses in the same direction deserve scrutiny.
2023: The downturn was much deeper than forecast
In its late-2022 outlook, NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun projected that existing-home sales would decline 6.8% in 2023. The final result was 4.09 million sales, down from 5.03 million in 2022—a decline of approximately 18.7%.
That is a miss of roughly 11.9 percentage points. The actual drop was nearly three times the forecast decline. Buyers and sellers who relied on a relatively mild slowdown narrative were not being shown the full depth of the contraction.
NAR's own 2023 outlook described the expected decline as 6.8%. Its later annual data recorded 4.09 million existing-home sales for 2023.
2024: The promised recovery did not arrive
As 2024 approached, the expectation was that sales would rebound. In May 2024, Yun projected 4.46 million existing-home sales for the year, a 9% increase from 2023. But the final 2024 total was approximately 4.06 million—slightly below 2023's 4.09 million.
Instead of the forecast 9% increase, sales slipped by roughly 0.7%. That is a gap of nearly 10 percentage points between the forecast and the result. By November 2024, Yun publicly acknowledged that the expected 2024 recovery had not happened.
The forecast was reported by Florida Realtors in May. NAR's January 2025 release confirmed the 4.06 million annual result, and its November 2024 remarks acknowledged the missing recovery.
2025: Another 9% rebound forecast, another flat year
In November 2024, NAR forecast that existing-home sales would rise 9% in 2025. The actual full-year total was approximately 4.061 million, compared with 4.062 million in 2024. In practical terms, the market was flat—down by about one thousand transactions.
A forecast of 9% growth followed by essentially zero growth is another miss of approximately nine percentage points. It also meant the market remained near a 30-year low in annual transaction volume.
NAR's November 2024 forecast set the 9% target. NAR's published annual sales history later recorded 4.06 million sales in both 2024 and 2025.
2026: A 14% prediction was cut repeatedly
The most recent example is still unfolding, so it should not be described as a final annual miss. In November 2025, NAR forecast that existing-home sales would jump 14% in 2026. By June 2026, the association's public outlook had been reduced to 4% growth. By October, Yun was projecting approximately 2% growth or less.
That is a dramatic reduction in the expected recovery before the year was finished. Meanwhile, the October 2026 existing-home sales report showed a 3.75 million seasonally adjusted annual rate, down 5.5% from September and 8.8% from a year earlier. The median price was still up 0.4% year over year, so this was evidence of weak transactions—not proof of a national price collapse.
The distinction matters: the 2026 annual result is not final, but the original 14% rebound forecast has already been cut to a much smaller expectation while the latest reported sales pace remains below the prior year.
See NAR's original 14% forecast for 2026 and the October 2026 report on the successive revisions.
The October sales figures are in NAR's October 2026 release.
A Pattern of Optimism Is Not the Same as a Reliable Outlook
Put the examples together and a pattern becomes visible. The 2023 contraction was far deeper than forecast. The 2024 rebound did not happen. The 2025 rebound forecast also failed to materialize. And the 2026 double-digit recovery call was substantially downgraded before the year was over.
There are legitimate reasons forecasts change: mortgage rates, inflation, employment, lending conditions, consumer confidence and unexpected events all affect housing. An economist should revise a forecast when the facts change. That is part of the job.
But the public should be able to see the original forecast, the revision dates, the final outcome and the size of the error in one clear record. A forecast should not disappear into a new narrative every time the previous one proves too optimistic.
The association's data releases can still be useful. NAR is a major source of transaction statistics, and its monthly sales reports help describe what has happened. The issue is treating the association's forward-looking commentary as if it carries the same reliability as the underlying historical data.
The Membership Incentive Deserves Public Scrutiny
NAR is not a neutral government statistical agency. It is a trade association whose mission includes representing and serving its members. That is a legitimate role—but it is also a reason the public should understand the organization's incentives when it communicates about the health of the profession and the housing market.
Real Estate News, reporting on NAR's 2024 IRS Form 990, described total revenue of approximately $360.8 million and characterized $303.5 million as member dues. HousingWire's separate review of the same filing, however, said less than $9 million appeared under the member-dues line, with much of the remaining revenue classified elsewhere. These published summaries conflict, and I have not independently reconciled the underlying filing categories. For that reason, I would not present a definitive dues percentage as fact. What is clear is that NAR is a large member-based trade association with a substantial public role and financial footprint. That institutional position is relevant context, but it does not prove that its economists tailor forecasts to protect membership revenue. See the Real Estate News analysis and the HousingWire analysis for the differing descriptions.
This does not prove that Lawrence Yun or anyone at NAR intentionally manipulated a forecast to protect membership revenue. I have not seen evidence that establishes that motive, and I will not present an inference as a fact. But the structural question is fair: when a trade association depends heavily on its membership base, should consumers automatically treat its public messaging about market strength and professional value as independent, disinterested analysis?
I do not think they should. The association has an institutional interest in demonstrating the importance and strength of the real estate profession. That does not make every forecast wrong or every statement misleading. It does mean the public should look at the numbers, the revisions and the outcomes—not simply accept a confident recovery narrative.
Why This Matters to Buyers and Sellers
For a seller, an overly optimistic forecast can encourage waiting for a recovery that may take longer than expected. That can mean more competing listings, additional price reductions, carrying costs and a different net result than the seller anticipated. The right decision still depends on the specific property, local inventory, comparable sales and personal timeline.
For a buyer, repeated predictions of a near-term rebound can create pressure to act before the market has actually strengthened. A buyer should not purchase because an industry forecast says activity is about to surge. The decision should be based on affordability, property condition, local competition, financing and how long the buyer expects to own the home.
National sales volume is not the same thing as local home values. Some markets can remain resilient while others weaken. A national forecast should never replace a property-specific analysis.
What I Believe the Public Should Demand
At a minimum, major industry organizations should make their forecast record easy to audit. That means publishing the original projection alongside every revision, showing the assumptions, measuring the final result against the initial forecast and explaining the size of the error—not just why the latest outlook has changed.
They should also distinguish clearly between what has happened, what is currently being measured and what is merely expected. A forecast is an opinion about the future, not a fact. Consumers deserve to hear the downside case as clearly as the upside case.
My criticism is not that NAR should never be optimistic. It is that optimism should not repeatedly be presented as the likely next chapter without equal candor about the evidence pointing the other way. When a public-facing organization speaks with authority, that authority carries responsibility.
In my opinion, when the same optimistic message keeps getting reset after the market fails to deliver, and when the organization communicating it has a significant institutional interest in the strength of the profession, the public is entitled to question whether the messaging is serving consumers—or the association's own interests. That is an ethical concern, even if intent cannot be proven from forecast errors alone.
A More Grounded Way to Read the Housing Market
I believe the U.S. housing market may be entering a longer downward cycle, although the timing and severity will vary by market. I do not expect a repeat of the 2008 collapse as a certainty; my view is that a future downturn could establish higher lows. That remains my opinion, not a guaranteed forecast.
I explained that broader outlook in I Believe the Housing Market Is Entering a Downward Cycle. Here's Why..
The point is not to replace one confident forecast with another. It is to encourage buyers and sellers to question assumptions, look at actual results and make decisions based on the property and market in front of them.
A Note for Central Florida Buyers and Sellers
If you are considering a move in Orlando, Winter Garden, Windermere or the surrounding Central Florida market, I can help you evaluate the specific property, competing inventory, recent closed sales and realistic negotiating conditions—not just a national headline.
Start a conversation with Ryan Brown at Own Luxury Homes® to discuss your plans.
Sources and Methodology
Forecasts are compared with reported annual existing-home sales totals. Percentage changes are rounded. The 2026 comparison is provisional because the year is not complete; it describes forecast revisions and the latest available monthly sales pace, not a final annual result.
NAR's 2023 outlook: 2023 Real Estate Forecast: Market to Regain Normalcy.
2024 forecast and final annual result: Florida Realtors forecast coverage and NAR's January 2025 sales release: https://www.nar.realtor/press-releases/existing-home-sales-ascended-2-2-in-december.
2025 and 2026 forecasts: NAR November 2024 forecast and NAR November 2025 forecast: https://www.nar.realtor/press-releases/nar-forecast-home-sales-expected-to-jump-14-in-2026.
2026 forecast revisions: Realtor.com, October 21, 2026.
2024 NAR financial reporting: Real Estate News analysis of NAR's 2024 Form 990.
NAR annual existing-home sales data: 2026 annual and historical sales tables.
This article reflects Ryan Brown's analysis and opinion. Forecast comparisons are based on the sources identified above. The discussion of institutional incentives is commentary, not an allegation that NAR or any individual knowingly falsified data. Housing conditions vary by location and property.


Comments